HTML Results

Scene name: bookshelf
Comparison time: 1800 seconds

Rendered imagesRelative Error (N/P false color)Abs X gradientAbs Y gradient
Reference Ours L2 Recons. Hachisuka and Jensen [2009] Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Reference Ours L2 Recons. Hachisuka and Jensen [2009] Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Reference Ours L2 Recons. Hachisuka and Jensen [2009] Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Reference Ours L2 Recons. Hachisuka and Jensen [2009] Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Comparison between our technique with L2 reconstruction, Hachisuka and Jensen [2009] and Manzi et al. [2015] with L1 reconstruction

Rendered imagesRelative Error (N/P false color)Abs X gradientAbs Y gradient
Reference Ours L1 Recons. Hachisuka and Jensen [2009] Ours L2 Recons.
Reference Ours L1 Recons. Hachisuka and Jensen [2009] Ours L2 Recons.
Reference Ours L1 Recons. Hachisuka and Jensen [2009] Ours L2 Recons.
Reference Ours L1 Recons. Hachisuka and Jensen [2009] Ours L2 Recons.
Comparison between density estimation techniques

Rendered imagesRelative Error (N/P false color)Abs X gradientAbs Y gradient
Reference Ours L2 Recons. Kettunen et al. [2015] L2 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L2 Recons.
Reference Ours L2 Recons. Kettunen et al. [2015] L2 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L2 Recons.
Reference Ours L2 Recons. Kettunen et al. [2015] L2 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L2 Recons.
Reference Ours L2 Recons. Kettunen et al. [2015] L2 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L2 Recons.
Comparison between gradient-domain rendering techniques (L2)

Rendered imagesRelative Error (N/P false color)Abs X gradientAbs Y gradient
Reference Ours L1 Recons. Kettunen et al. [2015] L1 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Reference Ours L1 Recons. Kettunen et al. [2015] L1 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Reference Ours L1 Recons. Kettunen et al. [2015] L1 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Reference Ours L1 Recons. Kettunen et al. [2015] L1 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Comparison between gradient-domain rendering techniques (L1)

Rendered imagesRelative Error (N/P false color)Abs X gradientAbs Y gradient
Path Tracing Bidirectional Path Tracing Kettunen et al. [2015] L1 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Path Tracing Bidirectional Path Tracing Kettunen et al. [2015] L1 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Path Tracing Bidirectional Path Tracing Kettunen et al. [2015] L1 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Path Tracing Bidirectional Path Tracing Kettunen et al. [2015] L1 Recons. Manzi et al. [2015] L1 Recons.
Comparison between path based techniques (L1)

Relative MSE